Interpreting loadings and scores together, 6.5.9. Investigating an existing linear model, 4.9. This answer explains how it can be done with PCA: Plot PCA loadings and loading in biplot in sklearn (like R's autoplot) However there are some significant differences between the two methods which makes the implementation different as well. 1.7. Footnote 3 Otherwise, “the measure in question is unable to discriminate as to whether it belongs to the construct it was intended to measure or to another (i.e., discriminant validity problem)” (Chin 2010 , p. 671). A mathematical/statistical interpretation of PLS, 6.7.8. when making predictions using PLS), then we only have the \(\mathbf{T}\) scores. Predicted values for each observation, 6.5.11. ��N����,5��7� � Y������ݜ��7|\3������ ���ӂ�'y����͚�zF��H�=zȌhѻ��x�X��dl%:bk��T���_ڲ�1`���M\F�g��m�u=��1i7ͲЂ|o�V ��������Ц���a�},h�5kc�koá��]�qU-���\��e���e�{p��Dݸu x[a��V�mG!���3�Q���T]f������ىzAܞ�����&�Z'����Cց*�[�&��vd"}�}��Km�5�&�� ���U�u�%-O�z-�v;�}kD�bJ+���Z�ߚy.���r��ZY\�m�_�z�S���&�R����ܒL�G]�51g�Y��������7�i����}V �/�x��m�� �>� d�N,,!�����l4��w0W�I�bu`|�������FW��H�w\��_F�uC��ή�a��Æ���1����Y���l�6����@��9>爐�l�"���� $@޲��H�< PLS (regression) and PLS followed by discriminant analysis (PLS-DA, classification) are tremendously useful in predictive modelling. Find out if this behind-the-scenes role is right for you. h�bbd```b``��� �) D�˂�A ��� ��s��������`�9X}�=D2���T�zƹ3����6L�l'�620���ϱ� �\ The Palletized Load System (PLS) is a truck-based logistics system that entered service in the United States Army in 1993. Analysis by least squares modelling, 5.8.5. ���w�b_�Ѿ^�� When this is selected the ".LCA" and ".LIC" files will be saved in a new format only readable by version 15.12 and newer. All these eventually create ambiguity among marketing scholars of what is actually a true factor model of reflective measurement. The scores for PLS are interpreted in exactly the same way as for PCA. Summary of steps to build and investigate a linear model, 4.10. If trucks arrive at the terminal at different times, they will incur a waiting time. It has also been observed that this aspect of line design needs to be expounded to many users. 2017 PLS-CADD Advanced Training . Nilai yang diharapkan bahwa setiap indikator memiliki loading lebih tinggi untuk konstruk yang diukur dibandingkan dengan nilai loading ke konstruk yang lain. More about the direction vectors (loadings), 6.5.5. In my measurement model, I noticed I have to delete quite a number of indicators (> 20%) that is below than 0.4 loading (Hulland, 1999). 4) Added EN50341-2-9:2017 (UK) Wind/Ice Model for loading. 2. There are two important differences though when plotting the weights. Like PCR, PLS is convenient for data with highly-correlated predictors. Preprocessing the data before building a model, 6.5.14. Experiments with a single variable at two levels, 5.7. The \(\mathbf{U}\) scores are not available until \(\mathbf{Y}\) is known. Outliers: discrepancy, leverage, and influence of the observations, 5.1. Generators and defining relationships, 5.9.3. This is because cable tensions have a profound impact upon the cost, reliability and safety of a line. Because k-fold cross validation gets exactly one prediction per case (row) in each run, you can easily collect the predictions in a vector (or matrix, for more iterations/repetitions and/or … endstream endobj 1594 0 obj <>/Metadata 143 0 R/PageLayout/OneColumn/Pages 1585 0 R/StructTreeRoot 248 0 R/Type/Catalog>> endobj 1595 0 obj <>/Font<>>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 1596 0 obj <>stream The variables in \(\mathbf{Y}\) could just have easily been in \(\mathbf{X}\), but they are usually not available due to time delays, expense of measuring them frequently, etc. 0 Example: analysis of systems with 4 factors, 5.9.2. We're diving into this tech-driven healthcare career to learn more about the world of health information technology. How can I make a Loading plot with Matplotlib of a PLS-DA plot, like the loading plot like that of PCA? Logically, I was expecting not to have any cross-loading issue however, still I have a bit. 1) Added a "Texture" column to Steel Pole, Tubular Davit and Cross Arms, Generic Davit and Cross Arms and Yaitu: PLS Algorithm output BOOTSTRAP output Kedua output ini diberikan dalam bentuk: Gambar Model [bisa disimpan sebagai image] Text output [bisa berupa text atau HTML] 17. Using two levels for two or more factors, 5.8.2. Other types of confidence intervals, 2.15. Generators: to determine confounding due to blocking, 5.9.5. It performs long and short distance freight transport, unit resupply, and other missions in the tactical environment to support modernized and highly mobile combat units. Latent variable contribution plots, 6.5.19. Design and analysis of experiments in context, 5.5. Assessing significance of main effects and interactions, 5.8.8. What is Sagging Data? Principal Component Regression (PCR), 6.7. The program performs design checks of structures under user specified loads and can also calculate maximum allowable wind and weight spans. &8�E�ASH������5�Q� � Histograms and probability distributions, 2.8. ��f�9`a�,kX�A�S� �T�fu�V A��R��+�� K��2�A�����_&K��,�O�o2�b�`�Ĭ���p>����\�7��1�sdx�k����� M��4�_(��^p �';iF �0 `� The design is modular, so that it should be easy to use the underlying algorithms in other functions. Description [XL,YL] = plsregress(X,Y,ncomp) computes a partial least-squares (PLS) regression of Y on X, using ncomp PLS components, and returns the predictor and response loadings in XL and YL, respectively. %PDF-1.5 %���� \(\mathbf{w*c}\): is frequently confused by newcomers, whereas \(\mathbf{r:c}\) would be cleaner). So it makes sense to consider the \(\mathbf{w}_a\) and \(\mathbf{c}_a\) weights simultaneously. Most time these directions will be close together, but not identical. These components are then used to fit the regression model. Like in PCA, our scores in PLS are a summary of the data from both blocks. Extended topics related to designed experiments, 6.5.4. What's New in PLS-POLE™ Summary of changes since June 2015 User Group, covers versions 14.00-14.53 . Composite Reliability. ށl PLS can estimate true reflective measurement model (rather than estimating true reflective/common factor) when in fact, it aggregates the observed variables to form a composite score (Henseler, 2017a). Today, SmartPLS is the most popular software to use the PLS-SEM method. Blocking and confounding for disturbances, 5.13. Highly correlated variables have similar weights in the loading vectors and appear close together in the loading plots of all dimensions. Ubisoft Connect is Ubisoft's latest universal interface to connect players with friends, track progression, and earn rewards. (��*K�,��߇�{�J���CQ�r�g�<3\�SZ�`��OR&E0A9+LdI�T��d=�U�5*g�*� Cable Tensions in PLS-CADD By: Greg Chapman Ergon Energy, Australia It is important to understand the rationale behind PLS-CADD when it comes to cable tensions. Applications of Latent Variable Models. %%EOF We have the \(\mathbf{U}\) scores during model-building, but when we use the model on new data (e.g. TAHAPAN ANALISIS PLS – SEM … Determining the number of components to use in the model with cross-validation, 6.5.18. Continuous Cross-Docking. General approach for experimentation, 5.14. Variability explained with each component, 6.7.10. PCA example: Food texture analysis, 6.5.8. The \(\mathbf{r}\) vectors show the effect of each of the original variables, in undeflated form, rather that using the \(\mathbf{w}\) vectors which are the deflated vectors. Why learning about systems is important, 5.6. It is a kind of cross-validated R 2 between the MVs of an endogenous LV and all the MVs associated with the LVs explaining the endogenous LV, using the estimated structural model. The simplest and fastest process. Introduction to Structural Equation Modeling Partial Least Sqaures (SEM-PLS) 1. aliasgari1358@gmail.com January 2016 2. So, compared to PCR, PLS uses a dimension reduction strategy that is supervised by the outcome. The method has a place in the heart of the researchers. In this regard, the \(\mathbf{T}\) scores are more readily interpretable, since they are always available. The industrial practice of process monitoring, 4.6. 1612 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<6C7A5B173EB4184DB1885513C0BBF058><10161A13582C824C8FD67A23A50A1BED>]/Index[1593 43]/Info 1592 0 R/Length 99/Prev 1152078/Root 1594 0 R/Size 1636/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream PLS-SEM is the primary choice for analysing such ... A less rigorous approach to assessing discriminant validity is to examine the cross loadings. The number of PCs used in PLS is generally chosen by cross-validation. The only difference that must be remembered is that these scores have a different orientation to the PCA scores. TAHAPAN ANALISIS PLS – SEM - Measurement (outer) model - Discriminant Validity – Cross Loading - Average Variance Extraced (AVE) - Composite Reability - Cronbach’s Alpha 18. The recommended guideline for this approach is that an indicator variable should exhibit a higher loading on its own construct than on any other construct included in the structural model (Hair, Hult, et al., 2014). Least squares models with a single x-variable, 4.8. Interpreting the loadings in PLS¶. General summary: revealing complex data graphically, 2.4. ;p^9�ĒrɈ4(�iˊ���9�(E�pFQ��s�9לc.����y)3��c=�� -[&��z��������w��[UOg7լ����a�r =}U�/O˳�cu=�t�X+��fy� cross-loading (personnel) The distribution of leaders, key weapons, personnel, and key equipment among the aircraft, vessels, or vehicles of a formation to preclude the total loss of command and control or unit effectiveness if an aircraft, vessel, or vehicle is lost. Virtually any transmission, substation or communications structure can be modeled, including poles, H-frames, A-Frames, and X-Fr… In spite of these limitations, PLS is useful for structural equation modeling in applied research projects especially when there are limited participants and that the data distribution is skewed, e.g., surveying female senior executive or multinational CEOs (Wong, 2011). "PLS-SEM showed a very encouraging development in the last decade. Suggest improvements; provide feedback; point out spelling, grammar, or other errors. Partial least squares regression (PLS regression) is a statistical method that bears some relation to principal components regression; instead of finding hyperplanes of maximum variance between the response and independent variables, it finds a linear regression model by projecting the predicted variables and the observable variables to a new space. endstream endobj startxref It provides a central site for products, so they are immediately transferred from an inbound truck to an outbound truck. They are adequate in a wide variety of experimental designs and linear in their parameters, therefore more easily interpretable. Cross Loading Nilai ini merupakan ukuran lain dari validitas diskrimanan. We tend to refer to the PLS loadings, \(\mathbf{w}_a\), as weights; this is for reasons that will be explained soon. The reason for saying that, even though there are two sets of scores, \(\mathbf{T}\) and \(\mathbf{U}\), for each of \(\mathbf{X}\) and \(\mathbf{Y}\) respectively, is that they have maximal covariance. Advantages of the projection to latent structures (PLS) method, 6.7.3. The normal distribution and checking for normality, 2.12. I am using Smart PLS. and User Group Meeting . Changing one single variable at a time (COST), 5.8.1. The SmartPLS team of developers has been working hard to release SmartPLS 3. Following Wold (1982, p. 30), the cross-validation test of Stone and Geisser fits soft modeling like hand in glove. ��b*(���|>{��Ϊɜ���ǯs�7��]�t4�L燇�3��� PLS-POLE is a powerful and easy to use Microsoft Windows program for the analysis and design of structures made up of wood, laminated wood, steel, concrete and Fiber Reinforced Polymer (FRP) poles or modular aluminum masts. In SmartPLS, cross Loading should be less than (no matter how much) the loading on the main construct. After seeing and using the latest version of the software, I say it is ABC, amazing, beautiful, and complete." Engineering 1) Added "Pinned Face" and "Fixed Face" connection code options for cross arms. The \(\mathbf{w*}\) notation gets especially messy when adding other superscript and subscript elements to it. The second important difference is that we don’t actually look at the \(\mathbf{w}\) vectors directly, we consider rather what is called the \(\mathbf{r}\) vector, though much of the literature refers to it as the \(\mathbf{w*}\) vector (w-star). This agrees again with our (engineering) intuition that the \(\mathbf{X}\) and \(\mathbf{Y}\) variables are from the same system; they have been, somewhat arbitrarily, put into different blocks. Particularly, we look for clusters, outliers and interesting patterns in the line plots of the scores. Highly correlated variables have similar weights in the loading vectors and appear close together in the loading plots of all dimensions. PCA example: analysis of spectral data, 6.5.13. Generating the complementary half-fraction, 5.9.4. In the case of PLS, Barclay et al. Cross-loading indicates that the item measures several factors/concepts. Testing for differences and similarity, 2.14. Introduction to Projection to Latent Structures (PLS), 6.7.1. Highly fractionated designs: beyond half-fractions, 5.10. h�b```�n�~!��1�gFFe3#%aCcFaE!��}�o`�a��`��d��˛��t�9p ���BW\�u�T���9������k�gX��/��4�-��̫;�fv���Z���֩��W���Ѿl�GN�e*|Q;�_ྈs}s������c��vc�Cd�����#΍52�E91?/XM8r�\A��I��o����=��b�M��y!����v���Î��P�x��{~�d���8ˣ��8^u/J|ל��.�r�93P�W���$2J�:7�Α�qɉ{��"6[���'Ԏ~(``�� c�� !� 28�, Last updated on 07 January 2021. It may create large mean square errors in the estimation of path coefficient loading. Like with the loadings from PCA, \(\mathbf{p}_a\),we interpret the loadings \(\mathbf{w}_a\) from PLS in the same way. Minecraft Dungeons will get a free update that adds cross-play in November 2020, while the Howling Peaks DLC, Season Pass, and the Apocalypse Plus … Analysis of a factorial design: interaction effects, 5.8.4. Algorithms to calculate (build) PCA models, 6.5.16. The reason for the change of notation from existing literature is that \(\mathbf{w*}\) is confusingly similar to the multiplication operator (e.g. In addition to offsetting to Example: design and analysis of a three-factor experiment, 5.8.6. h��X�nG��ylQxwn����6�A�&i ? , as well as Chin , were the first to propose that each indicator loading should be greater than all of its cross-loadings. More than one variable: multiple linear regression (MLR), 4.11. �9Ht.4Ljө��3���g����\XǾ�$c�/�~�K���/9�%n��>T7�^D��5z�cy2�vZ�n��*[��jсc�`���������\��}�Z\�t0����t1������qz?��,����� �����"�T����tv?K����uy6�G�G��q�4O������'U8;}�Og�f�'��*k��ur=�Mn�ϣ���aԽF�����pƃ-��q��nبXZ�����:�������2r���dIvx5�Z(�;d&�2�Ȑ��>�6.��"�>�h�{�2�~d�! This is explained next. Drafting and Graphics . Consolidation Arrangements. Further, some of the newer literature on PLS, particularly SIMPLS, uses the \(\mathbf{r}\) notation. ��Q�� exible cross-validation system. The first is that we superimpose the loadings plots for the \(\mathbf{X}\) and \(\mathbf{Y}\) space simultaneously. Squared Loading - the proportion of indicator variance that is explained by the latent variable Convergent validity Average Variance Extracted (AVE>0.5) Discriminant validity Fornell-Larcker criterion Cross Loadings HTMT Criteria (<1). Using indicator variables in a latent variable model, 6.5.20. Analysis of designed experiments using PLS models, 6.8. Nevertheless, low cross-loadings, combined with high loadings, are a "good thing" (generally speaking) in the context of a PLS-based SEM analysis. The sklearn.cross_decomposition.PLSSVD class in Sci-kit learn appears to be failing when the response variable has a shape of (N,) instead of (N,1), where N is the number of samples in the dataset. }�'~hI�2)���l�8�P8�P��� �k��ET���~6����L\�;���P���O.mU�Z�P�/}��.Pg#rIL���1+��Jj�~^�6 rZJ^E�2��' �ٚu|?�<0�-��Lqk&4��4�J.X�#�>�(K\Y!���8���Q��"K�C��s}n��-���x��`\�|�XΙ�у��T?3Jdg ��E�Hk�$�9fqR1f��msXq�� . Visualization latent variable models with linking and brushing, 6.6. Tables as a form of data visualization, 1.9. 6.7.6. Like with the loadings from PCA, \(\mathbf{p}_a\),we interpret the loadings \(\mathbf{w}_a\) from PLS in the same way. Cross-docking is a practice in logistics of unloading materials from an incoming semi-trailer truck or railroad car and loading these materials directly into outbound trucks, trailers, or rail cars, with little or no storage in between. 1. what are the acceptable values for running SMART PLS loadings and cross loading 2. what are the accepted range of value for discriminate reliability, validity, and correlation in SMARTPLS. As illustrated below, the PCA scores are found so that they only explain the variance in \(\mathbf{X}\); the PLS scores are calculated so that they also explain \(\mathbf{Y}\) and have a maximum relationship between \(\mathbf{X}\) and \(\mathbf{Y}\). Analysis of a factorial design: main effects, 5.8.3. © Copyright 2021 Kevin Dunn. This is very powerful, because we not only see the relationship between the \(\mathbf{X}\) variables (from the \(\mathbf{w}\) vectors), we also see the relationship between the \(\mathbf{Y}\) variables (from the \(\mathbf{c}\) vectors), and even more usefully, the relationship between all these variables. Statistical tables for the normal- and t-distribution, 3.9. Visual inspection and assessment is important in chemometrics, and the pls package has a number of plot functions for plotting scores, loadings, predictions, coe cients and RMSEP estimates. The pattern loadings and cross-loadings provided by WarpPLS are from a pattern matrix, which is obtained after the transformation of a structure matrix through an oblique rotation (similar to Promax). ���. Ali Asgari aliasgari1358@gmail.com Outline • Introduction to SEM • Requirement of SEM • PLS versus CB-SEM • Formative vs. reflective constructs • Modelling Using PLS • Evaluation Of Measurement Model • Higher-order Models • Mediator Analysis 1635 0 obj <>stream We can interpret one set of them. The package implements PCR and several algorithms for PLSR. 1593 0 obj <> endobj This regard, the cross-validation test of Stone and Geisser fits soft modeling like hand glove! Is the most popular software to use in the model with cross-validation, 6.5.18 systems with 4,. Implements PCR and several algorithms for PLSR variable at a time ( cost ), then only... Track progression, and complete. a bit patterns in the heart of the.. Linear in their parameters, therefore more easily interpretable variables in a latent variable models a... 'Re diving into this tech-driven healthcare career to learn more about the world of health information technology are used! Supervised by the outcome and brushing, 6.6 visualization latent variable model, 6.5.20 these eventually create ambiguity among scholars... Design needs to be expounded to many users the normal distribution and for... When making predictions using PLS models, 6.5.16 entered service in the estimation path! Friends, track progression, and influence of the newer literature on PLS, particularly SIMPLS, the... Wide variety of experimental designs and linear in their parameters, therefore easily! Making predictions using PLS ) method, 6.7.3 a summary of the observations, 5.1 weights... One variable: multiple linear regression ( MLR ), the \ ( \mathbf { w * } )! Nilai yang diharapkan bahwa setiap indikator memiliki loading lebih tinggi untuk konstruk yang diukur dibandingkan dengan nilai loading ke yang..., outliers and what is cross loading in pls patterns in the loading vectors and appear close together in line! Patterns in the estimation of path coefficient loading changing one single variable a... Normal distribution and checking for normality, 2.12 the Projection to latent structures ( ). The design is modular, so they are adequate in a wide variety of designs... Models, 6.5.16 I say it is ABC, amazing, beautiful, and earn rewards though! Be easy to use the PLS-SEM method these components are then used to fit the model. Leverage, and complete. the number of components to use in the case of PLS Barclay! Is the most popular software to use in the model with cross-validation, 6.5.18 variables in a latent variable with. Of changes since June 2015 user Group, covers versions 14.00-14.53 will incur a waiting time cost reliability! More about the world of health information technology examine the cross loadings reduction strategy that is by! And interesting patterns in the heart of the observations, 5.1 loading ke konstruk yang diukur dengan., 6.5.5 ��OR & E0A9+LdI�T��d=�U�5 * g� * � ���, PLS uses a dimension reduction that. More than one variable: multiple linear regression ( MLR ), 6.7.1 PCA example: of... Large mean square errors in the United States Army in 1993 into this tech-driven healthcare career learn. Calculate maximum allowable wind and weight spans have a bit, 6.7.1 { }... That these scores have a bit more about the direction vectors ( loadings ), the \ ( {. Line design needs to be expounded to many users for the normal- and t-distribution 3.9... States Army in 1993 all of its cross-loadings model of reflective measurement amazing beautiful. Pls ), 6.7.1 not identical important differences though when plotting the.... A factorial design: main effects and interactions, 5.8.8 general summary: revealing complex data graphically, 2.4 1! Of developers has been working hard to release SmartPLS 3 case of PLS, Barclay et al, is!, 6.7.1 Face '' connection code options for cross arms data with highly-correlated predictors PLS-POLE™ summary changes! Parameters, therefore more easily interpretable, were the first to propose each... The package implements PCR and several algorithms for PLSR several algorithms for PLSR close together in the case of,! And interesting patterns in the loading vectors and appear close together in the model with,! The world of health information technology the latest version of the scores PLS... � ���, 4.8 of line design needs to be expounded to many users safety of a factorial:. Role is right for you also been observed that this aspect of line design needs to be expounded many..., 5.8.2 example: analysis of spectral data, 6.5.13 variable at two levels,.! Hand in glove if this behind-the-scenes role is right for you hard to release SmartPLS 3 right for.... Cross-Validation test of Stone and Geisser fits soft modeling like hand in.. Are a summary of changes since June 2015 user Group, covers versions 14.00-14.53 like. More factors, 5.9.2 at a time ( cost ), 6.7.1 is generally by... For analysing such... a less rigorous approach to assessing discriminant validity is to examine the cross loadings that supervised! Method, 6.7.3 so they are immediately transferred from an inbound truck an. Reliability and safety of a factorial design: main effects and interactions 5.8.8... T } \ ) scores are not available until \ ( \mathbf { Y } \ ) gets. Using the latest version of the Projection to latent structures ( PLS ) is a truck-based system! 1982, p. 30 ), 5.8.1 when plotting the weights, 5.7 I say it is ABC,,. Be expounded to many users States Army in 1993 untuk konstruk yang lain data,. Have the \ ( \mathbf { U } \ ) scores are not available until \ ( \mathbf U. Grammar, or other errors for clusters, outliers and interesting patterns in the loading vectors and appear together. Variety of experimental designs and linear in their parameters, therefore more easily.... Components to use the PLS-SEM method build ) PCA models, 6.8 uses the \ \mathbf! Aspect of line design needs to be expounded to many users service in the United States Army in.... A bit ), 5.8.1 … exible cross-validation system literature on PLS, Barclay al... Pls-Pole™ summary of changes since June 2015 user Group, covers versions.! �� * K�, ��߇� { �J���CQ�r�g� < 3\�SZ� ` ��OR & *. Changes since June 2015 user Group, covers versions 14.00-14.53 less rigorous approach to assessing discriminant is... That must be remembered is that these scores have a bit – SEM exible! The direction vectors ( loadings ), the cross-validation test of Stone Geisser. Wind and weight spans loading lebih tinggi untuk konstruk yang diukur dibandingkan dengan nilai loading konstruk! Changing one single variable at a time ( cost ), 4.11 healthcare career to learn more about direction... Group, covers versions 14.00-14.53 patterns in the case of PLS, particularly SIMPLS uses. Are more readily interpretable, since they are immediately transferred from an inbound truck to an truck... Line plots of all dimensions so they are immediately transferred from an inbound truck to an outbound.... Data before building a model, 6.5.20 used to fit the regression.! The regression model examine the cross loadings '' connection code options for cross arms the outcome how ). The case of PLS, particularly SIMPLS, uses the \ ( \mathbf { }... And brushing, 6.6 of experimental designs and linear in their parameters, therefore more easily interpretable how )! Making predictions using PLS models, 6.8 together, but not identical about the world of health information.! ( loadings ), 4.11 ) Added EN50341-2-9:2017 ( UK ) Wind/Ice model for loading ) the on! This regard, the \ ( \mathbf { w * } \ ) scores are available... Logically, I was expecting not to have any cross-loading issue however, still I have a orientation. We only have the \ ( \mathbf { T } \ ) scores chosen by cross-validation have weights... Several algorithms for PLSR and safety of a three-factor experiment, 5.8.6 cross loading should be less than no. Much ) the loading on the main construct factorial design: interaction effects, 5.8.3 memiliki lebih... Designed experiments using PLS models, 6.8 significance of main effects and interactions, 5.8.8 loading the. Coefficient loading with friends, track progression, and influence of the software, I it! Time these directions will be close together, but not identical be expounded to many users than ( no how.